G4 model for Security Council reform

Context

India has recently presented a detailed model on behalf of the G4 nations for Security Council reform.

About 

• India presented the ‘G4 model’ on behalf of Brazil, Germany, Japan and India for debate, communication and finally negotiations.
  • The proposals elicited robust aid from wider UN members.
• New Members: It proposes that the Security Council’s membership increase from the modern-day 15 to 25-26, by adding 6 permanent and 4 or 5 non-permanent members.
• Regional Representation: Among the 6 new permanent members, two each are proposed to be from African states and Asia Pacific states, one from Latin American and Caribbean states; and one from Western European and Other states.
• Flexibility in Veto: The G4 model offered flexibility at the veto, even as the new permanent members would, as a precept, have the same duties and obligations as current permanent members, they shall not workout the veto until a choice on the problem has been taken throughout an assessment.
• Permanent Members aren’t Specified: G4 model does not specify which member states will occupy the new permanent seats.
  • This selection can be made by the General Assembly in a democratic and inclusive election.

About the UNSC

• The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) is one of the essential organs of the United Nations, responsible for keeping international peace and security. 
• It was hooked up in 1945 as a part of the UN Charter and consists of 15 member states, together with 5 permanent individuals with veto power—China, France, Russia, the UK, and the United States—and 10 non-permanent members elected for 2-year terms through the General Assembly.
• It is established in New York City.

Need for the Reforms in the UNSC

• Current Composition: The cutting-edge composition of the Security Council has below-illustration and un-representation of key regions.
• Inability to Address Conflicts: The current composition of the council has an incapacity to cope with critical conflicts and hold international peace and security.
• Changes in World Order: The world has passed through sea trade for the reason that 1945 and the new realities need to be pondered in the permanent membership.
  • Any idea that does not deal with the issue of representation of the Global South, inclusive of Africa, Asia and Latin America, in the permanent class does a grave injustice to the aspirations of growing nations for equality.
• Veto Power: Currently, most effectively the 5 permanent individuals preserve veto powers and via its use have stalled motion in the Council to deal with international challenges and conflicts consisting of in Ukraine and Gaza.
  • The remaining 10 countries in the Council are elected to sit down as non-permanent members for 2-year terms and do not have veto powers.
• Legitimacy: The disproportionate strength held with the aid of the 5 permanent members, especially their veto energy, can lead to a notion of unfairness and absence of legitimacy.

Limitations in Introducing the Reforms in UNSC

• Veto Power of Permanent Members: Any reforms to the composition or working strategies of the UNSC require the approval of the 5 permanent members.
  • These countries have divergent pastimes and are reluctant to assist adjustments that could reduce their influence in the Council.
• Regional Dynamics: Regional rivalries and geopolitical tensions complicate efforts to reform the Council.
• Complexity of the Reform Process: Amending the UN Charter to enact reforms requires a lengthy and complicated method regarding ratification by a huge variety of member states, making it difficult to enact important reforms.
• Chinese Opposition: China being a permanent member blocks the increase of India turning into a Permanent Member.

Way Ahead

• It is critical that both the permanent and non-permanent membership be representative of the world as it’s miles these days, not the world because it existed within the wake of the Second World War.
• Reforms inside the UNSC are crucial for keeping its relevance, legitimacy, and effectiveness in addressing the complicated security challenges facing the worldwide community in the 21st century. 
• However, accomplishing consensus on such reforms among the various UN’s member states remains a hard and ongoing process.

Source: The Hindu

UPSC Mains practice Question

Q.Discuss India’s position in getting closer to permanent membership of UNSC.(250 words)

1. India presented the ‘G4 model’ on behalf of Brazil, Germany, Japan and India for debate, communication and finally negotiations.
2. Regional Representation: Among the 6 new permanent members, two each are proposed to be from African states and Asia Pacific states, one from Latin American and Caribbean states; and one from Western European and Other states.
3. Flexibility in Veto: The G4 model offered flexibility at the veto, even as the new permanent members would, as a precept, have the same duties and obligations as current permanent members, they shall not workout the veto until a choice on the problem has been taken throughout an assessment.
4. Permanent Members aren’t Specified: G4 model does not specify which member states will occupy the new permanent seats.

Download as PDF