Women’s Reservation Bill 2023: Gender Equality

Context

The passage of the Women’s Reservation Bill 2023 marks a critical juncture in India’s journey toward gender equality. While it represents a historic rebalancing of political power, it also underscores the complexities of addressing gender equity in a polarized socio-political landscape. 

The Women’s Reservation Bill: A Historic Milestone

Key Provisions of the Bill

• The Constitution (One Hundred and Sixth Amendment) Act, 2023 reserves one-third of all seats in the Lok Sabha (lower house of Parliament), state legislative assemblies, and the Delhi Legislative Assembly for women.
• One-third of the seats reserved for Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) are also earmarked for women.
• The reservation will be implemented after the first census following the commencement of the Act, likely after 2026, and will remain in effect for 15 years.

Historical Context: The demand for women’s reservation in legislative bodies has been long-standing. The first Women’s Reservation Bill was introduced in 1996 but lapsed due to lack of consensus. Subsequent attempts in 1998, 1999, 2008, and 2010 faced similar challenges. The passage of this Bill in 2023 reflects decades of advocacy by women’s rights activists and civil society.

Significance and Impact

Enhanced Representation

• Women currently constitute only about 14% of Lok Sabha members and even less in state assemblies. This is far below the global average of 26.5%.
• The Bill ensures that at least 33% of seats are reserved for women, potentially increasing their representation to 181 seats in the Lok Sabha alone.

Challenging Patriarchy

• Increased female representation can challenge entrenched patriarchal norms and make political discourse more inclusive.
• Policies shaped by women legislators are likely to address issues such as gender-based violence, healthcare, and education more effectively.

Grassroots Empowerment

• The success of reservations at the panchayat level has demonstrated how quotas can empower marginalized women leaders.
• The Bill provides a pathway for grassroots leaders to transition into state and national politics.

Global Commitments

• The legislation aligns with India’s commitments to international frameworks like the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDG 5) and the Convention on Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW).

Challenges and Criticism

• Delayed Implementation: The reservation comes into effect only after delimitation based on the post-2026 census. Critics argue this delay undermines its immediate impact, particularly for the upcoming 2024 general elections.
• Risk of Tokenism: There are concerns that political parties may treat women candidates as mere placeholders or field them in losing constituencies. Proxy representation by male relatives could dilute the transformative potential of this legislation.
• Exclusionary Nature: The absence of sub-quotas for Other Backward Classes (OBCs), minorities, Dalit, and Adivasi women has drawn criticism. Critics argue that without intersectional representation, marginalized groups within women may remain underrepresented.
• Limited Scope: The reservation does not extend to the Rajya Sabha or Legislative Councils where women’s representation is also abysmally low. This creates an incomplete framework for gender parity across all legislative bodies.

Broader Implications

• Polarization Around Gender Equity: The mainstreaming of gender equity through this legislation has paradoxically made it harder to engage critically with its nuances. In a polarized world, debates often reduce complex issues like feminism to binaries—support or opposition—leaving little room for constructive dialogue.
• Intersectionality in Feminism: The Bill highlights the need for intersectional feminism that addresses not just gender but also caste, class, and community-based inequities. Without this lens, policies risk being exclusionary.
• Lessons from Global Practices: Countries like Rwanda have successfully implemented quotas that transformed their political landscape; women occupy over 60% of parliamentary seats there. India can draw lessons from such examples to ensure that reservations lead to meaningful empowerment rather than symbolic representation.

Way Forward

To maximize the impact of the Women’s Reservation Bill, several steps are necessary:

• Timely Implementation: Expedite census operations to ensure reservations can be implemented sooner rather than later.
• Ensuring Genuine Representation: Political parties must commit to fielding capable women candidates beyond reserved constituencies.
• Inclusion Through Sub-Quotas: Introduce sub-reservations for OBCs, minorities, and other marginalized groups to ensure intersectional representation.
• Capacity Building: Invest in leadership training programs for women at grassroots levels to prepare them for higher political roles.
• Expanding Scope: Extend reservations to Rajya Sabha and Legislative Councils to achieve comprehensive gender parity.

Conclusion

The Women’s Reservation Bill is a landmark step toward gender equity in Indian politics but is not without its challenges. Its delayed implementation and exclusionary aspects highlight the need for sustained advocacy and policy refinement. In a polarized world, fostering inclusive feminism requires moving beyond tokenism toward systemic change that addresses multiple layers of inequality.

Source: The Hindu

Download as PDF