UPSC Editorial Analysis
Transgender Day of Visibility: From Celebration to Real Change
Syllabus: Indian Society [GS Paper-1]

Image Credit: statcan.gc.ca
Context
- On March 31 each year the world marks International Transgender Day of Visibility as its designated observance. The day exists to recognize both the values of transgender people and their courageous spirit. The day functions as a reminder which highlights the various difficulties transgender people continue to encounter particularly within the Indian context.
- Transgender demographics in India receive limited progress through the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 while enduring problems with discrimination and social stigma and limited opportunities in everyday life. The law and society are still considerably distant from each other in their practices.
Laws Are There, But Implementation Is Weak
Through the 2019 Act India took a major stride toward establishing rights and implementing recognition for transgender citizens. In practical terms the legislation provides insufficient benefit to its stakeholders.
- Most transgender individuals encounter significant difficulties when trying to obtain their required ID documents which include certificates.
- The Identity certificate issuance reached just 15,800 out of the total 24,115 applications by December 2023.
- Transgender people continue to wait despite the expiration of time limits.
- Delhi issued only twenty-three transgender identity cards throughout 2022 when their population totals in the region exceeded four thousand.
- Slow and unfair implementation practice demonstrates how access to documentation won’t solve the problem.
Major Challenges Faced by Transgender People
- Economic Exclusion
Transgender people encounter many obstacles to attaining economic opportunities and employment freedom although these fundamental rights should be equally accessible for everyone.
-
- According to a 2018 survey by the NHRC, 92% of transgender population remained outside the employed sector.
- Men and women who identify as transgender frequently take unsafe economic opportunities such as street begging and commercial sex because they cannot secure suitable employment.
- The results of a 2022 study indicated that unemployment affected 48% of transgender individuals while the standard employment rate remained between 7% and 8%.
- Workplace Discrimination
-
- The practice of denying employment opportunities to transgender individuals and their unfair treatment within the workplace continues to exist in multiple organizations.
- People who manage to find employment need to deal with inappropriate and hostile treatment along with limited access to gender-inclusive bathrooms and inadequate organizational support.
- Tata Steel stands as one of the few organizations that implements inclusive hiring practices though such cases remain scarce.
- The creation of joint bank accounts remains challenging for lesbian, gay, bisexual, queer and trans people.
What Needs to Be Done?
- Better Education and Awareness
-
- The education system needs improvement because transgender students regularly endure bullying aside from facing harassment and lacking institutional support.
- The findings from the 2011 Census revealed that transgender individuals achieved only 56.1% literacy while the overall national average stood at 74.04%.
- Discrimination forced a total of 58% of transgender students from schools within Kerala to discontinue their education.
- The development of transgender student support differs between states because there exists no unified national policy.
Key solutions:
- Gender-sensitive books and teaching
- Safe and inclusive school environments
- Financial aid and vocational training
- Reservation in hostels and educational institutions
- Access to Health Care
-
- The discrimination towards transgender people results in regular rejections for medical assistance.
- Research data indicated that 27% of transgender persons encountered healthcare providers who declined to offer them treatment.
- Most health service areas do not properly implement the ₹5 lakh per year health insurance benefits provided by the Ayushman Bharat TG Plus card.
- Gender-affirming surgeries cost between ₹2 to ₹5 lakh although the complete coverage remains limited.
- The available number of trained doctors and mental health professionals unable to meet the requirements of transgender health care services.
What can help:
- The medical field should receive training on how to meet the health requirements of transgender patients.
- All transgender procedures should receive complete coverage together with extensive mental health assistance.
- Open special clinics for transgender people
Changing Society’s Mindset
- Policies along with laws can only succeed with the transformation of societal attitudes.
- Transgender people are starting to appear more frequently in public yet media outlets predominantly portray them through unflattering or oversimplified representations.
- The Humsafar Trust gets support from ‘I Am Also Human’ campaigns as positive initiatives for change.
- The Koovagam Festival of Tamil Nadu helps celebrate cultural identity although broader action is required to achieve full success.
Suggestions:
- Broadcasting media needs to display factual narratives along with polite depiction of transgender characters.
- The acceptance of transgender experiences needs to grow at all places where people learn and work and in family homes.
- All members of society need to recognize transgender individuals for their right to receive equal respect and equal opportunities as any other person.
The Road Ahead: Turning Visibility Into Empowerment
- True societal change demands meaningful involvement from every group within society.
- Government protocol requires proper law compliance while conducting assessments on program effectiveness.
- Government authorities should implement education policies which sustain transgender students throughout their academic journey starting from elementary education and continuing through secondary education.
- Health providers need to establish diverse and budget-friendly health services that serve transgender people.
- Organizations along with employers need to actively seek transgender candidates and nurture their career advancement.
- The media should work toward dismantling prejudices and supporting respect for everyone.
- Civil society organizations need to maintain their work of awareness distribution while developing communities.
Conclusion
- A yearly celebration for transgender individuals does not satisfy the core requirements. Real inclusion demands the respect of rights together with equal opportunities and complete backing for transgender people through their educational journey and into employment and healthcare resources.
- Through coordinated efforts among governments and companies and educators alongside media organizations and society we will create a future which acknowledges transgender people through respect along with empowerment as they gain full participation across all life domains.
Source: The Hindu