
Image Credit: The Hindu
Context
Although the number of persons sentenced to death by trial courts has increased rapidly, there is a significant trend of judicial restraint by the Supreme Court in confirming any death penalty over the last three years due to concern about injustice in conviction.
Key Highlights
- There is a massive judicial change in India in the system of death penalty.
- The Supreme Court has not affirmed any death sentence in three years in a row.
- Such a trend is also in contrast to high rates of death sentences given by the Sessions Courts, which casts doubts on the issue of wrongful convictions and the quality of criminal justice.
Key Findings from the Report
- As stated in the Square Circle Clinic (NALSAR University of Law):
- In 2025, the Supreme Court cleared 10 death row convicts, the most in 10 years.
- In the last decade, there have been 1310 death sentiment verdicts through Sessions Courts.
- The statistics reveal the increasing dissimilarity in the way of capital punishment is addressed by trial courts and constitutional courts.
Supreme Court’s Evolving Approach
- Judicial restraint of the Supreme Court has been on the rise in approving death penalties.
- The Court has stressed on numerous occasions:
- The “rarest of rare” doctrine.
- The necessity of individualised sentencing.
- Socio-economic background and potential of reform are examples of mitigating factors to be considered.
- Concerns about recent acquittals are:
- Faulty investigations.
- Circumstantial evidence.
- Lapses in procedures and poor legal representation.
Trial Courts and the Problem of Over-Sentencing
- Sessions Courts keep imposing death sentences at an alarming rate making the death sentence to be often awarded under pressure of the people and the media.
- Some of the causes of such a trend are:
- Weakness in the consistency of sentencing principles.
- Little focus on mitigating situations.
- Excessive use of confessions and poor forensic evidence.
- The rate of acquittal on appeal levels is high, which means that there are structural flaws at the trial level.
Concerns Over Wrongful Convictions
- The release of death row convicts who have spent years in prison creates acute constitutional issues.
- Long death sentence imprisonment will lead to:
- Psychological trauma.
- Article 21 (Right to Life and Dignity) was violated.
- The statistics reinforce the claims that the death penalty is:
- Irreversible.
- Prone to judicial error.
- Not equally applied to the poor and marginalised.
Constitutional and Ethical Debate
- India has maintained the death penalty in exceptional cases, however, the world trend indicates that more of them are being abolished.
- Critics argue:
- Death penalty deterrence value is not proved.
- Another option can be life imprisonment without remission.
- Supporters claim:
- It acts as a retributive justice to heinous crimes.
- It represents outrage in the society in severe instances.
Way Ahead
- Enhance sentencing policy in order to make uniformity in courts.
- Enhance forensic capacity and quality of investigation.
- Provide good legal assistance during trial.
- Take into account the legislation and judicial review on:
- The death penalty is a retention or an abolition.
- Increase in the application of reformative and restorative justice.
- Sentencing hearings in capital cases should be institutionalised as compulsory.
Source: The Hindu
Mains PYQ
(Q) Instances of the President’s delay in commuting death sentences has come under public debate as denial of justice. Should there be a time limit specified for the President to accept/reject such petitions? Analyse. (2014)
- Three consecutive years were affirmed by the Supreme Court on zero death sentences.
- Already in 2025, 10 death row prisoners were acquitted.
- On the trial courts, death penalties are still being handed out in large numbers.
- Information reveals the risk of false conviction.
- New argumentation on whether to reform or abolish capital punishment.



.png)



