fbpx
Daily Current Affairs for UPSC

CAPF Officers Move SC Over IPS Deputation Contempt

Syllabus- Polity and governance [GS Paper-2]

Context

Retired Central Armed Police Force (CAPF) officers have filed a contempt petition in the Supreme Court claiming that they have not fulfilled the 2025 order of the Court which commands progressive reduction of IPS deputation in CAPF.

Key Highlights

  • The Supreme Court in the case of Sanjay Prakash and others vs Union of India, 2025 decided that:
  • CAPFs officers, who are group A, are to be considered as an Organised Service on all matters.
  • The IPS deputation to Senior Administrative Grade (SAG) i.e. up to the rank of Inspector General (IG) in CAPFs should be gradually minimized in an outer limit of two years.
  • Currently, 20 percent posts in the rank of Deputy Inspector-General (DIG) and 50 percent in the rank of Inspector-General (IG) at the CAPFs are quota posts that are occupied by the IPS officers.
  • Objective of the Ruling: The decision was to provide the cadres officers of the CAPF with a fair career advancement as well as to prevent the long held superiority of the deputed IPS officers in the CAPFs.

Role of Ministry of Home Affairs 

  • The ministry of home affairs (MHA) is the administrative body of the Indian police service (IPS) and the central armed police forces (CAPFs).
  • The MHA has always defended deputation of IPS officers on following reasons;
  • Introduction of state cadres policing experience in order to reinforce central forces.
  • Ensuring that the leadership in all of the forces is standard.
  • Even after the Supreme Court order, at least eight IPS officers have been appointed to high posts in the CAPFs since the decision of May 2025.
  • These are appointments to command and Inspector General.

IPS appointment issues in CAPFs

  • Lack of Promotions and Career Advancement: CAPF cadres officers have low promotional chances because high reserves (e.g., 50% officers in the IG) are applied to IPS officers.
    • The average time taken by a CAPF officer to become a Commandant is 25 years which ought to be attained by the officer within 13 years.
  • Breach of Organisational Integrity: The further deputation of IPS officers is detrimental to the institution autonomy and professionalisation of CAPFs as elite forces in the long term.
  • Breach of Natural Justice and Equality: Articles 14 (Right to Equality) and Articles 16 (Equality of Opportunity in Public Employment) will be applicable, since CAPF cadres officers are not provided with equal promotional opportunities as IPS counterparts.

Policy Recommendations

  • Application of the SC Order: MHA should develop a transition strategy to eliminate IPS deputation in SAG and higher posts within two years as indicated.
    • Cadre reviews of all the CAPFs and revision of Recruitment Rules (RRs) to provide promotions based on merit and experience based in the CAPFs.
  • Parliamentary Oversight: Anyone who is interested should have a Parliamentary Standing Committee review to look at the deputation practices and career stagnation in CAPFs.
  • Clear Deputation Policy: Have a clear policy regarding inter-cadre deputations, establishing clearly the eligibility, period and objective requirements.

Source: The Hindu

Mains PYQ

(Q) “Institutional quality is a crucial driver of economic performance”. In this context suggest reforms in the Civil Service for strengthening democracy. (2020)

image_pdfDownload as PDF
Alt Text Alt Text

    Image Description





    Related Articles

    Back to top button
    Shopping cart0
    There are no products in the cart!
    0